Tournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 6 | Opponent: Greenhill VA | Judge: Luke Stuttgen
I value morality
First, ought is consistency with function. Macintyre:
(Alasdair Macintyre, After Virtue)
Yet in fact… a good watch.
Prefer this interpretation since
The only way to have a coherent set of values is to look at the constitutive features on an agent. Geach:
(Geach, P.T. “Good and Evil.”)
This sort of example… or the like.
Hence, the standard is abiding by institutional function
Further prefer the standard since
Most consistent with common language
The agent whose function or purpose must be evaluated is the lawyer
Lawyers bridge the client and the law.
Textually, the lawyer is the one who makes the decision on whether or not to disclose the info from the client.
I contend that a “good” lawyer is one who follows through with his function to unconditionally defend a client. Fried:
Fried, Charles. “The Lawyer as Friend: The Moral Foundations of the Lawyer-Client Relation” The Yale Law Journal. Vol. 85: 1060, 1976
First, it is said…(the professional's time) would dictate.
Lawyers need to serve to fully protect their rights to the client.
To deny the secrecy between client and attorney destroys the ability for a lawyer to defend his client. Noonan:
Noonan. John T. Jr. “The Purposes of Advocacy and the Limits of Confidentiality.” Michigan Law Review, Vol. 64, No. 8 (Jun., 1966), pp. 1485-1492
However, the secrecy… and keep it confidential.