Tournament: Meadows | Round: 1 | Opponent: Harvard Westlake CJ | Judge: Olivia Gover
Part 1 is theory:
prefer reasonable aff interps
presume aff
7 side bias
-need to weigh theory against that
fairness is comparative- anything i can do so can you
CX checks

PICs/CP don't prove the converse of res

presume aff
-times skew
-change advocacy

Part 2 is framework:
v) m
Function determines the moral nature:
Smith
Smith, Michael; “On Normativity”; http://www.princeton.edu/msmith/mypapers/OnNormativity.pdf
"Thomson argues for... a goodness-fixing kind"

MacIntyre explains ethics (After Virtue Pg 47-48)
"the counter example...of each other"

Objects get their purpose from the agents who construct them; a house is built for shelter, so a good house keeps out the rain. Cronk explains:
Cronk, Greg. "Reaction Paper on Sartre." Bergson.edu. Bergson, n.d. Web. 29 July 2013
"to explain this...is a choice"

The standard is maintaining consistency with the function of the United States criminal justice system.

Part 3 is the offense:
I contend that the function of the criminal justice system is created for a truth-seeking function rather than giving rights to those guilty of crimes. Landyoo:
The Origin of Language “The Criminal Justice System” 2011 http://theoriginoflanguage.com/the-criminal-justice-system/
"The criminal justice...wrong you are."

Also, if you don’t buy that, the Department of Justice in its Mission Statement  explains its function as:
http://www.justice.gov/about/about.html Department of Justice
"To enforce the... for all Americans."

Part 4 is the Underview:
First, the representation of the individual is actually helped under the affirmative world. Zacharias :
"If the client...and well represented"

Second, the costs of the attorney-client privilege outweigh the protection of individual autonomy. Goldfarb :  
"One can also...that once incident"

Lastly, ethics that terminate in rule making are circular. The primary dilemma of morality is that action-based ethics terminate into arbitrary axioms as it exists within a closed system, therefore it cannot say anything meaningful about the state of affairs outside that system. Alisdair Macintyre writes:
"An agent can...can be given"